Meditations on violence, by Sgt. Rory Miller
Meditations on violence, by Sgt. Rory Miller
A comparison of Martial Arts Training & Real World Violence
From Amazon reviews:
I’d always had a nagging feeling about my martial arts training; though there was no question it was good for my health, I was never too sure it was really relevant to self defense. The scenarios we practiced had nothing in common with the (few) *actual* violent encounters I had witnessed, which were short, brutish, and entirely unfair. (And for some reason didn’t involve “Needle to Sea Bottom” or a Gracie-esque arm bar.) Since I live a pretty staid life, my training never gets tested.
Which is unlike the author of this book — a jail guard involved in physical confrontations on a near daily basis. In this book Rory Miller pretty much devastates the notion that what goes on in most martial arts classes has anything in common with the fights and strategies he’s observed in his work. He details types of confrontations, the people likely to be involved in them, and strategies they’re using, and the often critical flaws in the way students are “prepared” for them by movies or the dojo.
As such, this is pretty much required reading for anyone taking or teaching martial arts for self-defense.
He doesn’t offer a specific training program as a solution — which is kind of the point. He’s asking the reader to chew on the facts, not the fantasies. Fights aren’t likely to be fair, or resemble sparring sessions. But they do have predictable participants, patterns and dynamics — from the “Group Monkey Dance” to the “permission” that people give themselves to go on or give up.
By Chowderhead (Oregon, USA)
My bits
Great book, another 5/5 .
Notes from the book
[ SORRY I had to delete this, after I read the copyright law...]